Select 1 keeper

[Eric JordanParticipant 4]

12 team PPR
6pt Passing TD

Keep 1 – Lose the round they were picked in 2022

Pick in spot 7

Saquon Rd 2
Fields Rd 12
Mattison Rd 12
Rachaad White Rd 13

[Rob LazerParticipant 53]

I would say anyone but Barkley, just because of the value. Barkley might still be there in the 2nd when you pick. All of the other guys will not be close to available at their previous draft round. I would lean towards White, just because it’s PPR and it’s a 13 round pick. I know alot of people are gonna say Mattison, but because the Vikings are going to be more pass happy and less involved in running the football, I don’t think he will have as much value as White. Ultimately, anybody but Barkley.

[Charles FoxParticipant 591]

On Rob Lazer said

<p>I would say anyone but Barkley, just because of the value. Barkley might still be there in the 2nd when you pick. All of the other guys will not be close to available at their previous draft round. I would lean towards White, just because it’s PPR and it’s a 13 round pick. I know alot of people are gonna say Mattison, but because the Vikings are going to be more pass happy and less involved in running the football, I don’t think he will have as much value as White. Ultimately, anybody but Barkley.</p>

I think I agree. But, I also don’t believe in Fields. Do you have a feeling for the league?. If you kept Barkley that would be at pick 18, which would not be terrible IF RBs usually fly off the board. Arguably if everybody is keeping 1 then Getting Barkley at 18 might be more like getting him at 24ish depending upon the ADP of players who are kept.

FWIW Pro Football Focus has Barkley ranked at 9 and Fantasy Pros has him at 12. Smitty only has him at 18

• This reply was modified 1 year, 5 months ago by Charles Fox.

[Eric JordanParticipant 4]

On Charles Fox said

On Rob Lazer said

<p><p>I would say anyone but Barkley, just because of the value. Barkley might still be there in the 2nd when you pick. All of the other guys will not be close to available at their previous draft round. I would lean towards White, just because it’s PPR and it’s a 13 round pick. I know alot of people are gonna say Mattison, but because the Vikings are going to be more pass happy and less involved in running the football, I don’t think he will have as much value as White. Ultimately, anybody but Barkley.</p>
</p>

<p>I think I agree. But, I also don’t believe in Fields. Do you have a feeling for the league?. If you kept Barkley that would be at pick 18, which would not be terrible IF RBs usually fly off the board. Arguably if everybody is keeping 1 then Getting Barkley at 18 might be more like getting him at 24ish depending upon the ADP of players who are kept.</p>
<p>FWIW Pro Football Focus has Barkley ranked at 9 and Fantasy Pros has him at 12. Smitty only has him at 18</p>

RBs fly off the board.
This is a tough decision. I agree the value of White is outstanding.

[Z-DubbsParticipant 224]

I rank Barkley as a top 12 player. You are getting him at 18 or 1.5. If you use that metric, Mattison has better value followed by Barkley, and then white.

Scoring ops – Barkley > Mattison > White.
Offensive importance and comp – Barkley > White > Mattison

Safe pick is Barkley
Value/risk is Mattison
I never keep QB’s so moot

I personally would go Mattison
Barkley is going to get his and a good starting point. Could still be there when picking though.
Mattison could lose his job by mid season or have 1,550 and 10 – but a 12th round pick mitigates a lot of that and no shot he is still there.
White’s line sucks, they do not have a QB, and I do not think Bowles is a head coach in ‘24. I do not think his talent can overcome.

[Author]

Posts