I picked JT because Achane has Mostert AND Wilson to concede carries from week 6-17;
JT could do one of the following so he also scares me (but I prefer his competition and drive to get paid)
– win you the league by being the RB1/RB2 for the rest of the season – Colts could run him into the ground and then trade him in the off-season
– lose you the league as Irsay says ‘screw you…sit while you are healthy’ – while Achane runs all over the league given Wilson and Mostert both going on IR by week 9.
But, like Chris said Achane has more hurdles. I own Achane in 3 leagues, 2 of them dynasty and plan to keep him for a 15th round pick in a 2-3 keeper league.
But, if I did not already own JT in the keeper league I would likely trade Achane for him. Fortunately, I took a flyer on JT in round 8, so I also plan to keep him for my 8th round pick.